
Our correspondent caught up with the ghost of Ned Ludd, who has been observing us closely for 200 years and wants to wrap up some unfinished business. The following interview has been edited for length and exactitude.
JT: I thought Ned Ludd was a symbol, not a real person.
Ned: Yes, some say I’m a made-up legendary folk hero. They compare me to Robin Hood who, like me, operated out of Sherwood Forest to champion the poor. But real or not, I inspired an army of dispossessed textile workers. For a time, greedy factory owners quaked upon receiving letters of demand signed by “General Ludd.” So I think I’ve earned the right to clear up some misconceptions about me and my comrades.
JT: You seem pretty agitated. Please explain what we’re getting wrong.
Ned: How many times have you joked about your “Luddite” grandpa who can’t figure out how to FaceTime his grandchildren? Or sheepishly referred to yourself as a “Luddite” because you hate social media or can’t update that Excel spreadsheet or would like to throw your smartphone out the window?
Or maybe you proudly say “I’m not a Luddite” because you embrace technology. You love self-driving cars (you just hope they learn to see flashing red lights on school buses) and the self-checkout aisles that let you avoid human contact at the grocery store. You’d be lost without your Apple Maps. Nope, you’re “not a Luddite.”
Well, you’ve fallen for a myth the British manufacturing class manufactured about us Luddites: that we were technology-phobic, progress-hating, ignorant, brutish dumdums.
JT: Okay, what were you then?
Ned: Let’s try a little thought exercise. Imagine you’re a master framework knitter, highly skilled on your equipment, making stockings in Northern England in the early 1800s. You actively experiment with technological innovations like frame modifications to create new lace patterns, finer weaves, and better fabric finishes. Though your cottage air is thick with dust and you eat way too much bread and potatoes, you control your working hours and pace and make a decent living.
Not far from you, some enterprising men decide to set up factories using wide stocking frames, which churn out large sheets of cloth, cut up into cheap, poor-quality items. The owners bring in children from orphanages and workhouses to run them, under brutal and dangerous conditions.
Now you find you can’t compete, there’s no job for you, and your way of life is gone. You, and many like you, are desperate to feed your families. Some of your comrades’ family members starve to death.
It’s illegal for workers to “combine,” but you have advocates who petition for measures like a minimum wage, a phased introduction of machinery to give artisans time to adapt, prohibition of inferior goods that defraud consumers, and a tax on machinery-dressed cloth to fund unemployment relief. Parliament deems your proposals a “most pernicious precedent” of interference in the free market.
You start to meet with your compatriots, swearing oaths of secrecy, and you organize raids on the factories. By and large, you avoid hurting people; your target is the machinery, like the wide frame, that is “hurtful to Commonality.” Your goal is to stop the new entrepreneurs from enriching themselves without regard for the consequences.
You have many short-term successes and much popular support, but your uprising is doomed. Machine-breaking and oath-taking are made punishable by death. The powers that be mobilize against you using spies, informants, and the largest domestic military occupation in British history. Dozens of your comrades are publicly executed and others sent to Australian penal colonies. The industrialists win the day—though you’ve paved the way for big reforms decades later, like limiting child labor and legalizing unions.
Imagine that was your life—and now you find yourself the butt of a running joke.
JT: That’s horrible; no wonder you’re upset. Why do you think the myths about the Luddites are so enduring?
Ned: One of your esteemed economists, Paul Krugman, mused about why people dislike artificial intelligence. “Historically, Americans have been technology enthusiasts,” he says. “As a nation, we’re not Luddites.” Entirely missing our point; it’s not about technology per se, but how the capitalists use it.
From where I sit (or float, being a ghost), you most certainly are a nation of Luddites. Just about any time a new technology has threatened people’s way of life or livelihood, folks have rebelled. You’ve had lamplighters smashing electric lamps, the Wobblies’ “collective withdrawal of efficiency by the workers at the point of production” to fight automation, dockworkers resisting containerization and automated cranes, the Hollywood writers striking over automation of the creative process—to name a few. “Not Luddites” today are finding ways to “withdraw the efficiency” of surveillance cameras on your streets.
In my time, enslaved people in your country regularly sabotaged equipment on the plantations growing the very cotton we spun and wove in England. The year 1811—the year we started organized machine-breaking—also saw the largest insurrection by enslaved people in US history. Hundreds armed with planting tools and axes marched along the Mississippi, gathering recruits along the way, chanting “Freedom or Death!” and setting fire to five sugar plantations. In the end, 45 captured men were executed by firing squad, and their severed heads were displayed on spikes along the river as a terrorizing warning. Through coordinated political censorship the rebellion was deliberately omitted from history books for nearly 200 years.
A similar playbook—terror plus propaganda—was applied to my compatriots at that same moment across the Atlantic: gruesome public hangings for deterrence (the gallows were modified so that the prisoners’ entire bodies would be seen when they died), then erasure of our struggle—not by leaving us out of history books, but by systematically turning us into objects of ridicule. Which you folks are thoughtlessly perpetuating.
JT: Now I feel terrible. Maybe you can give us some advice about the big technology thing we have going on—artificial intelligence.
Ned: Okay, another thought exercise: Imagine your children, like ours, suffer through a seven-year apprenticeship, then discover that the job they have trained for has been wiped out. Oh wait, that’s exactly what’s happening to your children, after getting their degrees in computer science, marketing, accounting, quantum physics, what have you, because of AI. Hope you have a nice basement waiting for them.
AI has something to do with zeros and ones, I hear. I don’t understand it, but apparently its creators don’t either. To be honest, AI seems like a bloodless iteration of Frankenstein’s monster, from the story our friend Mary Shelly drafted as the last of us Luddites were being hanged—the story of an arrogant inventor unleashing his creation upon the world without regard to the consequences.
Good on the people fighting against data centers being snuck into their communities, using dirty energy and straining local resources. At least, unlike zeroes and ones, you can see them, like we could see the new textile factories spewing smoke and fouling the rivers. But you’ll need some more ways to make sure AI helps, instead of destroys, Commonality.
JT: It’s just so daunting. Maybe we should improve on some proposals you tried early on, before things get out of hand. Any final thoughts for us?
Ned: Work on changing the narrative. Affirm that technology can be wondrous, but that you do, in fact, have a significant anti-technology contingent in your midst. You have folks who hate technology that actually helps people and expands knowledge. They prefer measles to vaccines, fires and floods to windmills and solar panels, DOGE cuts to space telescopes, cavities to fluoridation. They doubt people landed on the moon (some in the ghost community are on the fence about that one, but I’m advising an open mind). These are the real technophobes, aren’t they?
JT: How about if, in honor of our lunatic health secretary pushing beef tallow and lard, we name them “Lardites”?
Ned: Ha ha, good one. You can tease your Uncle Bob for being a Lardite at Thanksgiving, when he gets started on Anthony Fauci or the climate hoax. But seriously, if you want to promote family harmony, turn the convo to psychopathic tech billionaires who want to become trillionaires at everyone else’s expense. No one likes them—just like our people hated the textile titans.
JT: Ned, thanks for sharing your insights. I’ll work on getting your message out. Safe travels!
Jennifer Thomas is a speculative fiction writer and occasional New Liberator contributor. You can read some of her stories at jenniferthomas.net. To prepare for her interview with Ned, she read Blood in the Machine: The Origins of the Rebellion Against Big Tech by Brian Merchant.



That's the way to tell history!
Brilliant!!